Bushnaq’s grandparents were Muslim Bosnians who left Bosnia for Ottoman Syria in the late 19th century after Austria-Hungary took control of Bosnia.

By Debbie Weiss, The Algemeiner

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani marked the Palestinian “Nakba” with an official City Hall video featuring a woman presented as a survivor of Israel’s founding war, but critics quickly identified her family as “European settlers” from Bosnia who left Arab-controlled territory.

The backlash came as leaders of mainstream Jewish groups said they would reject invitations to Mamdani’s “Jewish Heritage” celebration at Gracie Mansion on Monday evening.

The video, posted on Friday, features New York resident Inea Bushnaq, identified as a “Nakba survivor,” recounting her family’s departure from their home because, as she termed it, “the Zionists were coming into Jerusalem.”

“Nakba” is Arabic for “catastrophe,” a term Palestinians use for Israel’s founding and the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Arabs during Israel’s 1948 War of Independence.

The Palestinian demand for a “right of return” for the refugees’ millions of descendants is viewed by many Israelis and Jews as a call that would end Israel’s existence by demographic means.

Critics said the video’s assertion that the Nakba “continues to this day” echoed that position.

Text in the video says the Nakba refers to the “expulsion and displacement of more than 700,000 Palestinians between 1947 and 1949 during the creation of the State of Israel” and says Israel’s pre-state militaries, “the Haganah, Irgun, and Lehi militias, among others, destroyed more than 400 Palestinian villages and cities, killing thousands of Palestinians and carrying out dozens of massacres.”

“May 15 is the annual commemoration of the Nakba. For Palestinians, their displacement and the Nakba continue to this day,” the video text reads.

The video makes no mention of Arab attacks on Jews before and during the 1948 war; the invasion by Arab armies after Israel’s declaration of independence meant to eradicate the nascent state; the rejection of the UN partition plan that would have created a Jewish and an Arab state; or the expulsion of Jews from parts of Jerusalem that came under Jordanian control.

Speaking in a British accent in the video, Bushnaq, who is described as Palestinian-American, explains how keys have become a Palestinian symbol of the right to return. “You have the key but not the house,” she says.

Tom Gross, a Middle East expert, noted that the video omitted the expulsion of Jews from Arab countries while relying on what he called a flawed account of Palestinian history.

“Not only does Mamdani’s video fail to mention the numerically greater 850,000 Jews driven out of their homes in the Arab world, but he also can’t even get his narrative right regarding the so-called Palestinian Nakba,” he told The Algemeiner.

In a post shared widely on social media, Gross cited research by the historian and influencer who posts as J0sh_a to challenge Bushnaq’s portrayal as a Palestinian refugee.

“It turns out that the ‘Nakba Survivor’ who stars in Mayor Mamdani’s official NY City Hall Palestinian propaganda video yesterday is literally a ‘European settler,’” the post said.

Bushnaq’s grandparents were Muslim Bosnians who left Bosnia for Ottoman Syria in the late 19th century after Austria-Hungary took control of Bosnia.

The family later moved to Tulkarem, which came under Jordanian control after 1948, not Israeli control. Bushnaq was born in Jerusalem because of the city’s medical facilities, but her family remained based in Tulkarem, the post said.

Bushnaq’s father worked in England in the 1930s, returned to what was then known as Mandatory Palestine under British administration, and then, in 1948 the family chose to go back to England.

“They were not expelled, and no one forced them to move to England. In any case, Tulkarem and the old city of Jerusalem remained under Jordanian Arab control. No Arabs were forced to leave from Tulkarem in 1948,” Gross wrote.

“So, in summary, this is a European with no strong roots in the land of Israel, whose family made the decision to immigrate back to the continent of their grandparents instead of remaining under Arab control in what was part of Jordan after 1948.”

Critics also pointed to a poster seen on Bushnaq’s wall in the video. The “Visit Palestine” image was not Palestinian nationalist artwork, they said, but a Zionist-era tourism poster designed by Jewish artist Franz Kraus to encourage travel to the Holy Land.

“It is beyond ironic that the only person featured to represent Palestinian Arabs in his video appears to be someone from a recently arrived European settler family—from Bosnia—and not Arab at all,” he told The Algemeiner.

Gross also argued that Bushnaq’s family story pointed to a wider part of the history often left out of Palestinian nationalist accounts, saying many Arab families in the land in 1948 had arrived within a generation or two, drawn by British rule or by economic opportunities created by Jewish development.

He cited surnames such as Al-Masri and Masarwa, both linked to Egypt; Fayumi, from Fayum in Egypt; Ismaili, from Ismailia; Al-Horani, from Hauran in Syria; Sidawi, from Sidon in Lebanon; and Al-Hijazi, from the Hijaz in Saudi Arabia.

Jewish groups, leaders, and members of Congress slammed the post.

The UJA-Federation of New York accused Mamdani of leaving out critical context, writing on X that “the refugees you post about exist because 22 Arab states launched a war to destroy Israel” after rejecting the UN plan that also called for a Palestinian state.

Referencing the translation of Nakba, US Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL) wrote on X, “The only catastrophe here is a mayor of New York who lets antisemitic mobs run wild to terrorize law-abiding Jewish New Yorkers while he spreads anti-Israel propaganda.”

“Rewriting history to portray the existence of Israel itself as the original sin is not education or remembrance. It is propaganda,” said New York Assemblymember Sam Berger.

“This mayor constantly tries to market himself as an ally to the Jewish community while amplifying narratives that fuel hatred against the Jewish people.”

New York State Assembly member Simcha Eichenstein wrote, “Still wondering why hatred against Jews is so high in NYC? We have a mayor who is using government resources to disseminate a narrative and incite hostile propaganda.”

The post came the same day as anti-Zionist demonstrators gathered in Manhattan for Nakba Day rallies, with footage showing protesters carrying a Hezbollah flag, stepping on Israeli flags, shouting for Israel’s destruction, and confronting police.

The timing also contrasted with Mamdani’s own statement days earlier praising law enforcement for arresting a man accused of planning an Iran-backed attack on a New York synagogue.

Mamdani had said the arrest “comes amid an alarming rise in antisemitism across the country.”

“Let me be clear: Antisemitism, violent extremism, and terrorism have no place in our city. This kind of hate is despicable,” he said.

The UJA-Federation later said it would not attend Monday night’s Jewish American Heritage Month celebration at Gracie Mansion because it was being hosted by a mayor who “denies a core pillar of our heritage — the State of Israel as the homeland of the Jewish people,” according to a statement carried by the New York Post.

Mark Treyger, CEO of the Jewish Community Relations Council, said he would also skip the event.

His group organizes the Israel Day Parade at the end of the month, which Mamdani has said he will not attend, breaking with past mayoral practice.

New Yorkers “expect leadership that lowers the temperature, brings people together, and makes every community feel seen, respected, and safe, including Jewish New Yorkers,” Treyger wrote in an X post criticizing Mamdani’s Nakba Day video.

The post ‘Beyond ironic’: Mamdani’s ‘Nakba’ video features non-Arab woman critics say has European roots appeared first on World Israel News.

‘What we saw with our own eyes today is the result of this terrorist attack … I believe that Hamas should not live in this world.’

By Vered Weiss, World Israel News

Croatian, German, Italian, and Lithuanian parliamentarians, many of them visiting the country for the first time, arrived in Israel to see first-hand the devastation created by Hamas terrorists on October 7th.

They began with a briefing from an IDF officer before visiting the military morgue at the Shura army base near Ramla and viewed unidentified body parts.

The group then went to the Sderot Observation Center where they saw footage from Hamas terrorists who filmed their atrocities.

After the video, they were addressed by Superintendent Micky Rosenfeld, the Israel Police’s spokesman who explained the impact of the attacks, and that Sderot’s population, as the result of the Hamas massacre on October 7th, went from 30,000 to 2,000.

Rosenfeld also explained that 125,000 Israelis are displaced from the North and the South of the country and are living in hotels.

The group then visited the burned and broken remains of Kibbutz Kfar Aza and were led on a tour by Israel Lander, a resident of Kfar Aza for 30 years.

Lander spoke of his own family’s survival, the 63 residents who were murdered by Hamas, and the others who were taken hostage.

The parliamentarians were profoundly affected by the visit and many came away with a more informed perspective on the war between Israel and Hamas.

Italian MP Mauro Del Barba, from Italia Viva, told The Media Line, “We didn’t know how many fighters came from the Gaza Strip … so many more than 1,000. ”

Del Barba added, “We didn’t realize that they had a bigger plan than the one we saw and probably a plan to conquer the entire country and to provoke a big war.”

Italian Senator Francesco Arcieri said, “What we saw with our own eyes today is the result of this terrorist attack. I believe that the ferocity of Hamas is the ferocity of another world, and that is why I believe that Hamas should not live in this world.”

This trip and other delegations organized by Elnet are intended to allow European politicians to bear witness and share their impressions in their home countries.

Elnet’s Turkish-born Deputy Executive Director Yossi Abravanel said, “One way to do it is to bring politicians to Israel and show them the reality so they can testify in their media and in front of their people when they go back to Europe.”

Abravanel added that while 80% of US congressmen and senators have visited Israel, only 15% of their European counterparts have made the trip.

The post European MPs visit scene of Hamas massacre appeared first on World Israel News.