Analysis & Opinion

No, Trump is not committing war crimes in Iran – analysis

The Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps or its subsidiaries control and profit from the power plants Trump threatens to destroy. That alone makes them legitimate targets.

By Michael Rubin, Middle East Forum

One hundred legal scholars signed a letter arguing that President Donald Trump’s threat to target Iranian power plants and bridges could amount to war crimes if carried out.

Calling “The attack was a clear violation of the United Nations Charter,” the scholars declared.

“The conduct of the war, and statements of U.S. officials, also raise serious concerns about violations of international humanitarian law, including potential war crimes.”

On April 5, 2026, Trump wrote, “Tuesday will be Power Plant Day, and Bridge Day, all wrapped up in one, in Iran. There will be nothing like it!!! Open the F***in’ Strait, you crazy bastards, or you’ll be living in Hell.”

If the goal is to help free Iranians from an odious regime, Trump’s polemics can backfire. After all, the problem in Iran is not the country or its people, but rather the regime that represses them.

The minute the regime falls, the same infrastructure Trump threatens will become essential to rebuild and reintegrate the economy.

Military necessity might require targeted destruction, but the United States should wield its power with the precision of a scalpel, not an axe, let alone a flame-thrower.

Still, the accusation of war crimes, now accepted as fact by the New York Times among others, is ignorant, hypocritical, and overblown.

First, the ignorance: Few if any of the signatories understand the nuances of Iran or its economy.

The Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps or its subsidiaries control and profit from the power plants Trump threatens to destroy. That alone makes them legitimate targets.

Since the end of the 1980-1988 Iran-Iraq War, the Revolutionary Guard has expanded its reach throughout the civilian economy, slowly taking over most industries.

The independent labor union in Iran erupted largely because the Guard ignored labor regulations, failed to pay salaries, and ignored safety standards.

Today, Khatam al Anbiya, the economic wing of the Guard, controls up to 40% of Iran’s gross domestic product.

Extracting the Guard’s tentacles from the civilian economy will be the major challenge of the post-Islamic Republic era.

Second, the hypocrisy: If Trump’s mean words and threats of destruction amount to possible war crimes, where have these legal scholars been over the past 47 years, when, on almost every Friday, the Islamic Republic’s leaders led chants of “death to America?”

Nor did the Iranian leadership limit itself to rhetoric. Their support for terrorism and proxies across Lebanon, Iraq, Syria, and Yemen led to the deaths of more than 100,000 people.

Indeed, while the American legal scholars salivate about the possibility of labeling Trump as a war criminal, they remain silent that the regime he tries to oust massacred 40,000 over two days in January 2026; launched cluster munitions at Israel and specifically target civilian apartment buildings; and then attacked hotels and economic infrastructure in Gulf Arab states that had not joined the conflict with the U.S. and had forbidden Americans from using their bases.

The closure of the Strait of Hormuz and the targeting of civilian tankers from third nations only adds to the litany of Iranian crimes.

The legal scholars’ rhetoric is in some ways as overblown as Trump’s.

While they talk about the conflict as risking genocide, they ignore basic metrics. In many wars — Syria and Libya, for example — conflict drove mass displacement. Millions became refugees.

During the Iran conflict, United Nations officials acknowledged that more Iranians returned to their country than fled to it. The reason? Iranians understood U.S. and Israeli bombing was precise; they faced little risk from it.

The irony today is that while legal scholars seek to promote and reinforce international humanitarian law, their subjectivity and political agendas now undermine it.

Share
Published by
Yossi Licht
Tags: Donald Trump Iran War Crimes

Recent Posts

  • World News

Fetterman’s Democratic challenger was born in Gaza and ‘loves Hamas’

Fetterman accuses his Gaza-born Democratic primary challenger of sympathizing with Hamas, as Ahmed Moor calls…

5 hours ago
  • Arab-Israeli Conflict

Israeli military moved 3.5 million Palestinian photos to Amazon for AI surveillance

The photographs were transferred in early 2024 during Israel’s military offensive in Gaza.

6 hours ago
  • Videos

WATCH: Democrat influencer tries to humiliate former press secretary over Iran war support; it backfires spectacularly

Democrat social media influencer Harry Sisson claimed that if former White House Press Secretary Sean…

8 hours ago
  • Source-JFeed

’60 Minutes’: Iran hit at least 31 US sites

According to figures presented in the CBS report, 23 American troops have been killed and…

8 hours ago
  • Israel News

Likud to appeal election results in 190 Arab-sector polling stations as foreign-interference probe stalls

Likud was given the polling-station committee forms listing the names of voters at the stations…

8 hours ago
  • Videos

WATCH: IDF nabs two Hezbollah-affiliated terrorists in southern Lebanon raid

IDF forces arrested two Lebanese Brigade terrorists operating under Hezbollah’s direction in a raid near…

9 hours ago