Source-Algemeiner

US criticizes ICJ opinion on Israeli presence in Judea and Samaria

The advisory opinion by ICJ judges is not binding but carries weight under international law and may weaken support for Israel.

By The Algemiener and Reuters

The U.S. criticized “the breadth” of the top U.N. court’s opinion that Israel’s presence in Judea and Samaria is illegal, with Washington saying it would complicate efforts to resolve the conflict.

“We have been clear that Israel’s program of government support for settlements is both inconsistent with international law and obstructs the cause of peace,” a U.S. State Department spokesperson said on Saturday in an email.

“However, we are concerned that the breadth of the court’s opinion will complicate efforts to resolve the conflict,” the State Department added.

The International Court of Justice, or the World Court, said on Friday that Israel’s presence in Judea and Samaria and settlements was illegal and should be ended as soon as possible, delivering its strongest findings to date on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

The State Department said the ICJ opinion that Israel must withdraw as soon as possible from Judea and Samaria was “inconsistent with the established framework” for resolving the conflict.

Washington said that framework took into account Israel’s security needs, which it says were highlighted by the Oct. 7 attacks on Israel by Palestinian Islamist group Hamas.

Those attacks killed 1,200, with around 250 people taken as hostages.

Two-State Solution

The advisory opinion by ICJ judges is not binding but carries weight under international law and may weaken support for Israel.

The State Department said the way forward was through direct negotiations.

“Israeli settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and the regime associated with them, have been established and are being maintained in violation of international law,” ICJ President Nawaf Salam said on Friday while reading the findings of a 15-judge panel.

The court said Israel’s obligations include paying restitution for harm and “the evacuation of all settlers from existing settlements.”

Israel rejected the opinion and said a political settlement can only be reached through negotiations. The office of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas welcomed the opinion, which it called historic.

The State Department said it “strongly discourages” parties from using the ICJ opinion “as a pretext for further unilateral actions that deepen divisions or for supplanting a negotiated two-state solution.”

The ICJ case stems from a 2022 request for a legal opinion from the United Nations General Assembly.

Share
Published by
Yossi Licht
Tags: ICJ Judea and Samaria USA

Recent Posts

  • Videos

WATCH: Trump issues dire warning to Iran over Washington bomb threat

President Trump warned that Iran would pay an unprecedented price if reports of a potential…

46 minutes ago
  • Source-WIN

Mamdani orders NYPD to dismantle counterterror unit, drawing fire from Jewish groups

Jewish leaders warn that Mayor Mamdani is endangering New York Jews by disbanding NYPD counterterrorism…

2 hours ago
  • Source-WIN

Britain sanctions Israeli construction firms over projects in Judea and Samaria

British government imposes sanctions on eight Israeli construction firms over their operations in Judea and…

3 hours ago
  • Videos

WATCH: Turkish analyst calls for Islamic war to destroy Israel

Turkish political analyst Dr. Yusuf Katipoğlu openly declared that Turkey is calling on the Islamic…

3 hours ago
  • Source-JNS

Rubio, Vance offer contrasting visions of ‘America First’ ahead of 2028

Neither Rubio nor Vance has declared that he will run for the presidency in 2028,…

4 hours ago
  • World News

Iran planning ‘dirty bomb’ assassinations of Trump officials: Report

A source described the potential weapon as an instrument of terror capable of causing widespread…

4 hours ago