World News

7 major US Jewish groups decline meeting with French official after ‘premature Palestinian state recognition’

Israel is furious about France’s recognition, which comes just months after Macron said he would not make such a move without Hamas surrendering and releasing the Israeli hostages it holds.

By Philissa Cramer, JTA

Seven major U.S. Jewish organizations say they have rejected a meeting with a French minister out of protest over French President Emmanuel Macron’s announcement Thursday that he would recognize a Palestinian state.

The move makes France the largest Western country to offer recognition, which 140 other countries have already extended but Israel and the United States oppose.

Critics of unilateral recognition say the creation of a Palestinian state should come only through negotiations involving Israel.

France’s Minister for Europe and Foreign Affairs Jean-Noel Barrot approached one of the groups, the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, to meet in New York to discuss the recognition move. It declined.

“We are disappointed that our organizations were invited to discuss a policy that appears to already have been finalized rather than being consulted beforehand as partners committed to sustainable peace,” the groups said in a joint statement.

The other groups joining the Conference of Presidents in issuing the statement are six of its member organizations: the Anti-Defamation League, the American Jewish Committee, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, B’nai B’rith International, UJA-Federation of New York and the World Jewish Congress.

“We are deeply concerned that France’s approach undermines prospects for a mutually negotiated future for Israelis and Palestinians,” the groups said, adding, “By taking such a unilateral step, France not only emboldens extremists, but risks the security of the Jewish people around the globe, along with alienating moderate voices and undermining the credibility of French diplomacy in the region.

Barrot, who delivered a letter outlining Macron’s announcement to Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas on Thursday, has rebuffed such criticism.

“Hamas has always rejected the two-state solution,” he tweeted on Thursday. “By recognizing Palestine, France proves this terrorist movement wrong. It supports the side of peace against that of war.”

Israel is furious about France’s recognition, which comes just months after Macron said he would not make such a move without Hamas surrendering and releasing the Israeli hostages it holds.

Foreign Minister Gideon Saar tweeted on Friday that he had discussed the move with his Canadian counterpart and warned her that Israel is considering an unspecified response.

“Unilateral steps by France and other countries will only push Israel to take steps of its own,” he wrote. “The French initiative harms the chances of achieving a hostage deal and ceasefire. It won’t promote stability in the region.”

William Daroff, the Conference of Presidents’ CEO, said the decision to rebuff Barrot’s invitation did not represent a permanent policy.

“We routinely meet with foreign leaders, including when we disagree with their policies. However, in this case, the group of invited organizations unanimously agreed not to attend. Speaking with one voice underscores the seriousness of our objection,” he said in a statement. “Should we receive future invitations, we will evaluate them on a case-by-case basis.”

Share
Published by
Yossi Licht
Tags: American Jews France Two State Solution

Recent Posts

  • Jewish Diaspora & Antisemitism

2/3 of French Jews considering leaving country as antisemitism fears mount

New survey finds that nearly two-thirds of French Jews are thinking of leaving France over…

2 minutes ago
  • World News

Why is a third US aircraft carrier now in the Middle East?

The USS Theodore Roosevelt previously operated in the region during a deployment against Yemen's Houthi…

1 hour ago
  • Arab-Israeli Conflict

‘I pray that Hezbollah will disarm,’ says Trump official in Beirut

'Lebanese sovereignty must be fully restored,' U.S. envoy Mike Waltz said.

2 hours ago
  • Analysis & Opinion

Trump, Vance and Rubio: The battle for Israel and the GOP’s future

Trump's decision to pull Vance away from Iran negotiations exposes growing differences over the war,…

2 hours ago
  • Israel News

Arab walkout of national anthem during Knesset ceremony sparks push for loyalty oath

Likud MK pushes to require loyalty to Israeli flag and anthem after Arab lawmakers walkout…

2 hours ago
  • World News

Jewish heirs seek to halt Sotheby’s sale of $180 million Van Gogh

Its $180 million estimate exceeds Van Gogh’s auction record of $117.2 million.

3 hours ago