Israel News

Israel’s new justice minister clarifies remark that he’s prepared to disobey Supreme Court decisions

“We are not talking about decisions with which I happen to disagree,” Ohana countered.

By World Israel News Staff 

Justice Minister Amir Ohana has issued a clarification to an earlier statement he made in favor of disobeying court rulings, saying that he was referring only to “extreme” cases when lives are at stake.

In his first interview as justice minister, which he gave the same day he was sworn in, Ohana said he’d go against Supreme Court rulings if they went against his view of what’s best for Israel’s security.

Supreme Court President Esther Hayut, in a speech on Thursday, lashed out the new justice minister for espousing “an unprecedented and irresponsible judicial worldview according to which not all rulings handed out by courts should be honored.”

“Between this perception of the world and the anarchy of ‘everyone doing what’s right in their own eyes’ – the road is short,” she added.

In his clarification, Ohana said in a statement that when speaking of disobeying a court ruling, he had given “an example of an extreme case that happened in reality.”

His reference was to a 2004 High Court ruling that prevented the military from demolishing Palestinian structures near the Kissufim crossing into the Gaza Strip. Israel still controlled the Gaza enclave at the time, before its 2005 pullout.

The security establishment wanted the structures removed to prevent ambush terror attacks. Later, terrorists used one of the buildings as cover to murder a pregnant Israeli woman and her four daughters.

Ohana argues that the court decision should have been disregarded.

“We are not talking about decisions with which I happen to disagree,” Ohana countered on Thursday. “I was talking about the most extreme cases where… they could cost lives,” he said.

Ohana has been highly critical of Israel’s court system, charging that there are no checks and balances in the judiciary and advocating for change. He says there is a rift between the public and the judiciary.

He is also in favor of an Override Clause, which would give the Knesset the ability to override by a simple majority Knesset rulings that strike down laws duly passed by Israel’s parliament.

Share
Published by
David Jablinowitz
Tags: Amir Ohana Esther Hayut Israeli Supreme Court

Recent Posts

  • Israel News

Bringing Islamist party into gov’t could threaten Israel’s national security, defense minister warns

Defense Minister Israel Katz warns against Israeli-Arab party joining next government, citing Muslim Brotherhood's ties…

24 minutes ago
  • WhatsApp Brief

Netanyahu’s office investigated over alleged plot to discredit Israel’s election results

Israeli authorities are investigating whether Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office orchestrated election-day arrests to undermine…

2 hours ago
  • Israel News

Knesset member calls for changing Israel’s national anthem because it’s ‘Zionist’

Originally adopted by the Zionist movement, 'Hatikvah' expresses the Jewish people’s enduring hope for freedom…

10 hours ago
  • World News

USS Theodore Roosevelt to join two US aircraft carriers in Middle East as talks fail

American and Israeli officials have prepared plans for renewed strikes on Iran’s economic infrastructure.

11 hours ago
  • Videos

WATCH: Pence rebukes Vance for blaming Iran war for midterm losses

Former Vice President Mike Pence rebuked current Vice President JD Vance for blaming the Iran…

11 hours ago
  • Israel News

NYT: Mossad Abducted Two Iranian Generals in Hunt for Ron Arad 

Israeli intelligence assessments repeatedly questioned Iran’s involvement as investigators increasingly focused on a Lebanese village.

12 hours ago