Arab-Israeli Conflict

Hostage families ask Defense Minister Katz ‘Why are you making a Schindler’s List?’

Many of those present were critical of the phased release of hostages and wanted assurances that all of the captives would be freed.

By Vered Weiss, World Israel News

Family members of hostages interrupted a presentation by Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz at the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee (FADC) on Tuesday, and many were angrily critical of the current hostage deal that may be finalized within days.

The hostage family members spoke, interrupting the meeting for 30 minutes as Katz and Likud MK Yuli Edelstein sat in silence.

Many of those present were critical of the phased release of hostages and wanted assurances that all of the captives would be freed.

Chana Cohen, The aunt of one of the hostages whose daughter died in Hamas captivity, exclaimed, “Where is my daughter? Why is she not on the list?”

She added, “I want to bury my daughter in a Jewish cemetery.”

Cohen continued, “You cannot continue to live here. I will not let you speak today. Go from here, and instead of speaking about money, bring me my daughter.”

she added, “…it is all according to a pre-negotiated list.”

Many of the family members kept saying, “You have selected some hostages to live and some to die.”

One person yelled, “At Auschwitz, there was selection off the train” of who would live and who would die.”

Katz emphasized that although 33 hostages will be released in the first phase of the deal, he is committed to releasing all of the hostage according to the agreement.

Cohen responded, “Committed? How many more years? Why are you making a Schindler’s List?”

Danny Elgarat, brother of hostage Itzik Elgarat, had harsh words for the Defense Minister.

“Here sits a man accountable for selecting the hostages, responsible for the abandonment of 70 hostages in Gaza. He is the defense minister—but where is the defense? In truth, he is the minister of abandonment,” Elgarat said.

The hearing ended half an hour earlier than scheduled, after which Katz embraced the family members even as they continued to criticize him.

Share
Published by
Miriam Metzinger
Tags: hostage deal hostage families Israel Katz

Recent Posts

  • Israel News

Israel reclassifies crocodiles, opening door for Ben-Gvir’s prison moat plan

Ben-Gvir's proposal envisions using crocodiles as a living security barrier around prisons such as Ketziot…

8 minutes ago
  • World News

US strikes Bandar Abbas supply routes as Iran targets American positions across region

Using fighter jets, drones and warships, US forces struck military logistics hubs, coastal surveillance positions,…

1 hour ago
  • Israel News

Herzog: Peace With Saudi Arabia Remains ‘My Dream,’ Applauds Renewed Strikes on Iran

Herzog praised the Abraham Accords as a model for regional cooperation.

1 hour ago
  • Videos

WATCH: Former envoy Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg calls for Trump admin to do more than airstrikes

Former Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg urged President Trump to heavily target Iran's economy — specifically…

3 hours ago
  • Israel News

Israel’s parliament dissolves ahead of Oct. 27 elections

The last time Israel’s government fulfilled a full term without breaking for early elections was…

3 hours ago
  • Jewish Diaspora & Antisemitism

Jewish advocacy group blasts Australian higher education establishment over antisemitism revelations

The council also criticized universities’ inaction over the encampments and the presence on some campuses…

4 hours ago