Israel accepts 4 hostages despite Hamas violating deal

Israel had communicated its expectation that female civilian hostages, including Arbel Yehud, would be prioritized under the agreement.

By World Israel News

The list of Israeli hostages scheduled for release on Saturday, as announced by Hamas, includes female IDF soldiers Karina Ariev, Daniella Gilboa, Naama Levy, and Liri Albag.

Although Hamas published the list at 5:00pm, the IDF requested that Israeli media delay publication until the families of the hostages had been notified.

The Israeli government, however, has expressed strong reservations regarding the list, citing significant deviations from the terms of the agreed-upon deal.

Discussions are now underway between Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Defense Minister Israel Katz, and top security officials on how to address this breach.

The Disputed List of Hostages

According to an official statement from Netanyahu’s office, the names provided by Hamas do not align with the original agreement.

Under the terms of the deal, Hamas was also required to provide information about the status of the 26 remaining hostages who are slated for release in the initial phase.

This list would, for the first time, offer official information about the Bibas family—parents Shiri and Yarden, and their children Ariel and Kfir—who have been held in Gaza.

Escalating Concerns Over Civilian Hostages

A critical point of contention is the inclusion of female civilian hostages in the release schedule.

For each female civilian hostage released, the deal stipulates that Israel will free 30 Palestinian prisoners, while 50 prisoners are to be released for each female IDF soldier.

Israel had communicated its expectation that female civilian hostages, including Arbel Yehud, would be prioritized under the agreement.

However, Yehud’s situation highlights a complication: she is believed to be held by the Palestinian Islamic Jihad group rather than Hamas.

This has led to concerns in Jerusalem about delays in her release.

The agreement outlines a specific sequence for hostage releases. Any deviation from this order has significant implications for the trust and execution of the deal.

Israel’s Potential Responses

Hamas’ violation of the agreement has placed Israel in a challenging position.

The government has a range of options to consider, including withdrawing its commitment to allow Palestinians to return to northern Gaza or modifying the list of Palestinian prisoners slated for release.

The Palestinian prisoners include individuals serving life sentences for murder and other terror-related offenses, making their release a contentious issue domestically.

Any adjustments to the prisoner list could further complicate the fragile negotiations.

Next Steps in Negotiations

Amid these developments, high-level discussions continue between Netanyahu, his negotiating team, and international mediators.

The outcome of these talks will likely shape Israel’s response to Hamas and determine whether the agreement can proceed or if further complications will arise.

As tensions remain high, both sides are under pressure to uphold their commitments to the agreement.

For Israel, ensuring the safe return of hostages is paramount, while for Hamas, compliance with the terms may impact its standing in the ongoing conflict.

Daniella Gilboahamas hostageshostage dealKarina ArievLiri AlbagNaama Levy