Comments by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his defense minister, Benny Gantz, expose a growing rift just weeks after their coalition government was sworn into office.
By Associated Press and World Israel News
Israel’s top two leaders appeared to feud Monday about the timing of the country’s planned extenstion of sovereignty over parts of Judea, Samaria and the Jordan Valley, complicating the task of American officials who were in Jerusalem trying to finalize a plan.
The comments by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his defense minister, Benny Gantz, exposed a growing rift just weeks after their coalition government was sworn into office. It also raised questions about the viability of Netanyahu’s annexation plan.
Netanyahu has said he wants to begin acting on the sovereignty plan as soon as this week in line with President Donald Trump’s Mideast plan. Trump’s envoy, Avi Berkowitz, is in Jerusalem this week working with Israeli officials on the details of the plan.
But in a meeting with his Blue and White party, Gantz said his top priority is helping the country cope with the health and economic crisis stemming from the coronavirus.
“Anything unrelated to the battle against the coronavirus will wait,” he said.
U.S. officials have said they would like the plan to have the support of Israel’s two main parties, Netanyahu’s Likud and Gantz’s Blue and White. After three inconclusive elections, the two rivals formed a power-sharing government last month, with its primary focus on guiding the country through the coronavirus crisis.
Netanyahu, a close ally of Trump, is eager to push forward on sovereignty well ahead of November’s presidential election.
“A couple of months from now, I’m confident that that pledge will be honored, that we will be able to celebrate another historic moment in the history of Zionism,” the prime minister stated in a special online broadcast two months ago, directed at Evangelical Christians, marking the 100th anniversary of the San Remo Conference of 1920, an important milestone in Zionist history, which gave international backing to the Balfour Declaration.
Gantz, a former military chief who also holds the title of alternate prime minister, has been far more cautious, saying any annexation must be done in consultation with international partners.
Netanyahu appeared to dismiss Gantz’s concerns Monday, telling Likud members that he was working “discretely” with the Americans. “The issue does not depend on Blue and White,” he said.
Under their coalition deal, Netanyahu and Gantz hold mutual veto power over most government decisions. But the deal makes an exception for annexation, allowing Netanyahu to introduce a proposal to the Cabinet or to the full parliament even without Gantz’s approval. It remains unclear whether Netanyahu is prepared to do that.
Earlier on Monday, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Michelle Bachelet, said the plan would have “disastrous” consequences for the region.
“The precise consequences of annexation cannot be predicted,” Bachelet said in a statement issued by her office in Geneva. “But they are likely to be disastrous for the Palestinians, for Israel itself, and for the wider region.”
Israel’s Foreign Ministry accused Bachelet of politicizing her office and noted that it froze ties with her office early this year due to what it called her “one-sided” attitude.
“It is not surprising that she decided today to join the Palestinian campaign against the American peace plan, and to publish declarations before any decision has been made,” the ministry said in a statement.
The Trump plan, unveiled in January, envisions leaving some 30% of Judea and Samaria under permanent Israeli control, while granting the Palestinians autonomy in the remainder of the area.
The Palestinians claim all of Judea and Samaria, along with eastern Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip, for a fully independent state. Israel captured all three areas in the 1967 Six Day War, though it withdrew from Gaza in 2005, clearing the way for Hamas to seize control two years later.
Netanyahu has been unswayed by the criticism. He says the supportive Trump presidency has provided a rare opportunity to redraw the Mideast map and annex Israel’s scores of settlements, as well as the strategic Jordan Valley.
Both Netanyahu and Gantz have been meeting with Berkowitz and the U.S. Ambassador to Israel David Friedman to work on a final map outlining which areas will be annexed. The talks were continuing after a series of inconclusive meetings in Washington last week.
The plan has also come under surprising criticism from a number of settler leaders, who believe it does not go far enough and say that any plan that envisions even a watered-down Palestinian state must be opposed.
Netanyahu reportedly is considering scaling back his plans and is expected to annex just a small number of settlements in a largely symbolic move.
But Bachelet warned that even a small annexation would create a “highly combustible mix.”